One year ago, I started a large Single Page Application (SPA) project. I spent a few weeks Googling and biting my nails, trying to choose between the various options for SPA development. I considered four leading players:
- Knockout with Durandal
- Backbone with Marionette
A year ago this felt like anyone’s race. I ended up selecting Knockout with Durandal for the project since the combination offered clear support for older versions of IE. I currently develop apps for automotive dealerships and they’re notoriously slow to upgrade browsers. I enjoyed the development process with Durandal and Knockout and don’t regret my decision. There’s certainly no way I could’ve pulled off such a rich, interactive UI with solely jQuery.
Yet in the last year I’ve watched the tide shift heavily toward AngularJS.
Angular’s momentum has become clear at various conferences across the country. Perhaps the most obvious recent example was at FluentConf in San Francisco:
That’s a pretty striking contrast. Now given, one could argue high conference session counts are merely a sign that Angular is a lot more complicated! But there’s no denying Angular has massive momentum. Enough to settle into a long-term #1 spot on Pluralsight’s top 100 courses. Angular even recently spawned it’s own its own conference: ng-conf.
Today marked another huge landmark for the Angular project: Rob Eisenberg, Durandal’s creator and director, announced that Durandal is being merged with Angular. He quietly joined the Angular team a few months ago. And, going forward, there will be only maintenance releases for Durandal 2. So, Durandal’s upcoming convergence with Angular makes this basically a three horse race.
Angular has become the de facto standard for SPA development.
Why Has Angular Become so Popular?
I see three simple reasons:
1. Google Support – Sure, Google has a long history of killing promising projects. Remember Wave and Reader? But they’re a corporate powerhouse which lends a great deal of credibility to the project. Tell your boss you want to use a free framework from Google. That’s an easy sell.
2. Integrated and Opinionated – I enjoy working with Durandal, but ultimately you must rely upon multiple technologies to create a complex SPA using Durandal including Knockout for binding, RequireJS for dependency management, and a promise library (I went with Q.js). Backbone takes a similar approach – it’s not very opinionated so developers are free to make many architectural decisions on their own or to pull in libraries like Marionnette.
In contrast, Angular is highly opinionated and offers a single integrated solution. It’s analogous to the Unix and Windows model. In Unix you perform complex tasks by piping commands. The composition of many small targeted applications provides great power and flexibility. But the masses gravitate toward opinionated and integrated solutions like Windows. Why? A simple psychological principal called the tyranny of choice. In short, abundant choice often leads to misery. It’s easier to accept a few things you dislike in Angular than to be overwhelmed with decisions in other less opinionated libraries and frameworks.
The Future is Evergreen
I still have concerns about Angular. One must ask why Google is making this play at all. I believe it’s the same reason they built Chrome: Angular is Google’s new lever to push the web forward. That said, I worry that Google will push too aggressively on browser standards, thereby making the framework a non-starter for unlucky developers who must support older browsers. It’s clear Google prefers to err on the side of forcing the web forward. I admire this mission, but hate to see the developers supporting legacy browsers left with few viable alternatives.
Framework developers are starting to embrace a new ideal: Soon only Evergreen browsers will be supported by modern frameworks like Angular. This term, coined by Paul Irish has a simple premise: Evergreen browsers auto update. Most of today’s current browsers are Evergreen including Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and IE10+. This trend is great news for web developers who will soon be able to enjoy the power of ECMAScript 6 and the shadow DOM with Web Components. But it means customers should be warned now. Select an auto-updating browser ASAP – The web is surging ahead and Google will use AngularJS to lead the charge.
Chime in on Hacker News, Reddit or in the comments below.